Germany’s pouch ban isn’t working, and its drug commissioner just said so

Veröffentlicht auf:

Veröffentlicht in:

Germany is one of the few countries in Europe where you can’t legally buy a nicotine pouch. Authorities treat them as a novel food under EU food law, which means they can’t be placed on the market, and cities like Cologne have used that to order them off shop shelves. On paper, that’s a ban.

This week Hendrik Streeck, the German government’s commissioner for addiction and drug policy, described what that ban looks like in practice. Speaking on Sprechende Medizin, a podcast from the German Medical Association, he said pouches aren’t allowed to be sold in Germany, but that people bring them in from abroad and some shops sell them under the counter. The Swedish outlet Drugnews reported the conversation on 17 November.

We’ve been saying for a long time that this is what bans produce, and it’s useful to hear it from the person who runs German drug policy. The product hasn’t gone anywhere. It has moved somewhere without age checks or limits on nicotine content, where nobody pays tax on it either.

Klaus Reinhardt, president of the German Medical Association, was on the same episode and thinks the answer is a stricter ban. He wants pouches classified as tobacco products and then banned from sale, which would also cover imports and marketing, and he called that a sensible position for doctors to take. It’s hard to see what that changes for the people Streeck was describing, since they’re already buying a product that’s already illegal to sell.

Streeck’s main worry is young people, and flavours in particular. He mentioned cola, mango and strawberry kiwi as the kind of thing that pulls teenagers into nicotine, and he said no serious health policymaker sees any benefit in pouches. We’d push back on both points. On the first point, flavours help adults switch too. But most importantly, flavours are part of our lifestyle and we like them. Normal adults like flavours and nicotine is a normal substance that’s been part of our life for a long time. What protects underage people is getting rid of the black markets that sell to them. Also, in the US, the FDA authorised some Zyn pouches to be marketed as lower risk than cigarettes. 

Other countries in Europe have gone a different way. Sweden has sold snus and pouches legally to adults for years, and CAN, the Swedish council for information on alcohol and other drugs, puts daily smoking below 5%. Austria is planning to sell pouches through licensed tobacconists to adults only. In the UK, selling nicotine products to under-18s has been an offence since 29 October, and the government now has powers over strength, flavours and packaging. None of these systems is perfect, but each has a legal product with clear rules attached that allow pouchers pouch and that someone can actually enforce.

What bothers us most is what this means for women in Germany. According to CAN, daily smoking in Sweden has fallen most among women and young adults, and pouch use among Swedish women has roughly tripled since 2007. Those two trends are connected, and anyone who talks to Swedish pouch users knows it. A German woman who wants to make the same switch can’t buy a pouch legally, because her government has decided it doesn’t like the product. We think that’s unfair. She’s being kept away from the option that helped Swedish women bring their smoking rates down.

We also doubt the people pushing for a stricter ban have heard many success stories from people who quit this way. We hear them all the time, from women who’ve gone back to the gym because they can breathe properly again, who don’t smell of cigarettes any more, and whose families have stopped worrying that they’ll get cancer. None of that came up in the coverage of that podcast, which was about flavours and tax rates, but it’s exactly what a ban takes away.

Germany is sticking with tax and prohibition. The coalition has already agreed a 9% rise in tobacco tax for 2027, and Streeck wants much bigger increases because his priority is protecting young people.. We share that goal. We just don’t think a ban that the country’s own drug commissioner says people get around is the way to reach it.

Teilen auf:

Sie können auch mögen

Considerate Pouchers●

Germany is one of the few countries in Europe where you can’t legally buy a nicotine pouch. Authorities treat them...

Considerate Pouchers●

30 October. The FDA authorises 24 new nicotine pouches. 4 mg each. Lime, passion fruit, cinnamon. Child-resistant packaging. That’s 67...

de_DEDE